A full-floor co-op loft at 431 West Broadway came on the market on July 6 at $3,995,000. It is about 2,000 square feet above a long-established art gallery, with a cast-iron balcony over the street and a shared roof terrace. It went into contract 23 days later and closed on October 16 for $4,005,000, which is $10,000 over the asking price. Three blocks east, a 1,200-square-foot condo loft at 95 Greene Street took 85 days to find a buyer. It closed in July at $1.925 million, 12.5% under its $2.2 million ask.
Both are SoHo lofts in historic buildings, and both closed within the past four months. One closed above its ask and the other well below it. The gap tells a buyer more about this market than the median does, because SoHo's supply of homes for sale is close to fixed. When almost nothing new comes in, price per foot stays in a narrow band, and the only real variable is whether an existing loft was priced right the day it was listed.
The new buildings on the way are mostly rentals
Nearly five years after the 2021 SoHo/NoHo rezoning, most of the housing planned inside SoHo will be rented, and most of it is still years from move-in.
The furthest along is 130 Lafayette Street, the Trammell Crow building where SoHo meets Tribeca. New York YIMBY reported in July that it was past the halfway mark, with 99 rental apartments, some of them affordable, and completion expected in the first quarter of 2028. At 277 Canal Street, the 1927 Oltarsh Building that was once SoHo's first movie theater, a revised plan for a 21-story building with 159 homes, 31 of them affordable, went to the Landmarks Preservation Commission on July 28. At 30 Thompson Street, the site of a planned 19-story, 44-unit building, a permit for a construction fence was issued on October 2.
The for-sale part of the pipeline is small. According to CityRealty, at 392 West Broadway, an Italianate loft building from 1872, Cofinance Group won Landmarks approval in October 2025 to create a four-unit boutique condominium: three full-floor three-bedrooms and a four-bedroom penthouse with a private roof terrace. The same CityRealty roundup describes 40 Wooster Street, a few blocks away, as planned for four luxury rentals, including a duplex penthouse with its own pool.
The Village View reported last December on what Village Preservation's Andrew Berman told Community Board 2 that November. The city had projected 1,829 new homes in the rezoning area within ten years, and four years in, he counted none built. New condos are launching nearby but outside SoHo. In NoHo, 43 Bleecker Street is an 11-unit conversion by DLJ Real Estate Capital Partners that began sales this fall and is scheduled for completion in 2027. In Tribeca, a 1,948-square-foot three-bedroom at 14 White Street was listed on November 13 at $6.4 million, or $3,285 a foot.
For a buyer, that means the SoHo they can buy in 2027 will look very much like the SoHo of today, made up of cast-iron and loft buildings that have been trading among owners for decades.
A price per foot that has barely moved since 2022
Prices behave the way you would expect when the stock stays the same. In PropertyShark's quarterly SoHo figures, the median price per square foot has stayed between $1,786 and $2,161 in every quarter from the start of 2022 through the third quarter of 2026. In the third quarter of 2026 it was $1,980, up 2.4% from a year earlier. The median sale price that quarter was $3.505 million, down 6.3% from the third quarter of 2025.
The number of sales has changed more than the price. The first three quarters of 2022 saw 149 SoHo sales, while the same nine months of 2026 saw 95. With fewer homes trading and value per foot holding steady, each listing carries more weight. A buyer has fewer comparable sales to point to, and a seller has fewer competing listings to price against. Across the 31 sales in the third quarter of 2026, 15 were condos with a median of $4.2 million and 16 were co-ops with a median of $3.4 million. Groups that small move around from quarter to quarter, so the medians are useful as a general level more than as a measure of any one building.
Three weeks or three months
The closings and contracts from July through November, as recorded by CityRealty, show a clear pattern. Lofts priced at or near what buyers would pay went into contract in about three weeks. The ones that missed took two to three months and sold under their ask.
| Address | Type | Closed or contract | Price | Per sq. ft. | Versus ask | Days to contract |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 112 Prince Street #5 | Co-op loft | Closed Aug. 25 | $4.95M | about $1,980 | 5.9% over | 17 |
| 76 Crosby Street #4, The Bayard | Condo loft | Closed Oct. 30 | $13.5M | $2,566 | $5,000 over | 22 |
| 431 West Broadway #4 | Co-op loft | Closed Oct. 16 | $4.005M | about $2,003 | $10,000 over | 23 |
| 537 Broadway #4 | Co-op loft | Closed Aug. 31 | $5.2M | about $1,520 | 3.7% under | 49 |
| 95 Greene Street #2B | Condo loft | Closed July 24 | $1.925M | about $1,604 | 12.5% under | 85 |
| 459 West Broadway #5N | Co-op | Contract Oct. 1 | $7.6M ask | $2,413 ask | n/a | 77 |
| 92 Greene Street #4A, Mercer Greene | Condo | Contract Sept. 29 | $8.5M ask | $1,895 ask | n/a | 83 |
The fast sales did not share a building type or a price point. 112 Prince is a five-unit former toy factory. The Bayard is a six-unit condominium built in 1884. 431 West Broadway is a four-unit building from 1920 that became a co-op in 1972. Their prices ranged from under $5 million to $13.5 million, and each one closed at or above its ask. The slower sales are just as varied. 537 Broadway is a cast-iron building from around 1868 that was converted to a co-op in 1975, and 95 Greene is a cast-iron building from 1881. In each case, the asking price set on the first day decided how the sale went.
For a buyer, the two groups call for different approaches. A well-priced loft in SoHo now tends to go into contract within a month, so the buyer who wins it has financing and, for a co-op, a board package ready before the second showing. The two contracts signed this fall after 77 and 83 days on the market show where a buyer has room. In a market where per-foot value has held in one band since 2022, a listing that has sat for two or three months usually has an asking price problem, and the room to negotiate comes from that.
What a newer building costs here
The loft closings above fall between about $1,520 and $2,566 a square foot. Newer SoHo buildings sell well above that band. On August 17, the penthouse at 42 Crosby Street, a ten-unit boutique condominium built in 2016, closed at $28.25 million for 5,852 square feet, or $4,827 a foot. The penthouse last traded for $19.103 million in 2019.
That price per foot is almost double the best loft result in this fall's table. With 392 West Broadway's four condos the only new for-sale homes approved inside SoHo, that premium will apply to a very small number of homes for some time. A buyer who wants modern construction and is comparing SoHo with Tribeca is setting $3,285 a foot asked at 14 White Street against a handful of SoHo condos that rarely come up for sale. The buyer who settles on a loft is choosing from the stock in the table above, and that stock is not getting any bigger.
Small-building lofts can also carry an interior that changes the price. CityRealty reported that in August the north penthouse at 90 Prince Street, a condo in a historic loft building redesigned by architect Thomas Leeser, went into contract at a $6.35 million ask for 1,213 square feet, about $5,235 a foot. In SoHo, a known designer and a penthouse floor in an old loft building can be priced like new construction.
What long-held lofts sold for
Two October closings show how far SoHo loft values have moved over two decades of small supply. On October 8, a 4,497-square-foot loft at The Wooster Street Condominium, 50 Wooster Street, closed at $9.65 million, or $2,146 a foot. The unit last sold for $3.81 million in 2005. Two days earlier, a 2,200-square-foot co-op at 150 Thompson Street closed at $4.975 million, or $2,261 a foot. That unit last sold for $1.125 million in 2003.
Both sales sit in the same per-foot band as the fastest sales in the table. If you are thinking about selling a SoHo loft in the next year, these figures give you two reference points. A loft bought decades ago is already worth what this tight market supports. In the fall's sales, the asking price you choose on the first day decided whether you closed within weeks or after a long wait. Over the last four quarters, the market has rewarded careful pricing more than an ambitious first number.
For more context on the blocks themselves, our SoHo neighborhood guide covers the streets behind these addresses, and our August look at SoHo's side streets off Broadway covers the galleries and restaurants near many of these lofts. Buyers weighing a move one neighborhood south can compare with our Tribeca guide.
If you are weighing a SoHo loft this winter and want to know which listings are priced to go into contract in three weeks and which have room left after two months, schedule a private consultation with The Diamonde Team and bring the addresses you are watching.